Electrical Diagnostic Challenge
Evaluate measured multi-function tester (MFT) readings, earthing arrangements, and site symptoms. Commit to your diagnosis, receive immediate statutory analysis, and build verified practical competence.
Case 1: PME Open-PEN Fault at Mode 3 EV Charger
Reported Symptom
Customer reports a tingling shock when touching the vehicle bodywork while unplugging after an overnight charge. A second occupant standing on wet tarmac measured a sting on the door handle. The 7.4 kW Mode 3 wallbox remains energised and shows a green 'ready' LED. No RCD or MCB has tripped.
Plant & Installation Context
Domestic TN-C-S (PME) supply, Ze at origin historically 0.28 Ω. 7.4 kW single-phase Mode 3 tethered wallbox (32 A Type A RCBO, 6 mm² / 6 mm² SWA) feeding a metallic-bodied BEV on the drive. No dedicated TT earth electrode and no open-PEN detection device fitted. Main bonding to gas and water is present. Weather: wet drive, vehicle tyres on tarmac.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 2: High Zs on 32 A Radial — Table 41.3 Exceeded
Reported Symptom
Periodic inspection of a 32 A radial serving a commercial kitchen wall-mounted oven. Live Zs at the appliance terminals is 1.62 Ω. The circuit is protected by a 32 A Type B MCB (BS EN 60898) with no RCD. The oven works, but the inspector has recorded an unsatisfactory result against maximum Zs.
Plant & Installation Context
Three-phase TN-C-S board, 100 A DNO cut-out. Circuit: 32 A Type B single-pole MCB, 6.0 mm² / 2.5 mm² two-core-and-CPC PVC/PVC, 28 m run in surface trunking to a 32 A DP cooker-control switch then 6 mm² tails to the oven. Circuit installed c. 2009. No signs of thermal damage at the appliance. Board is a metal 18-way split-load DB; this MCB is on the non-RCD side.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 3: Star-Delta Changeover Instantaneous Trip
Reported Symptom
An 18.5 kW, 400 V, 32 A FLC squirrel-cage pump motor starts in star and runs up smoothly. At the star-to-delta transition the 40 A MCCB trips instantaneously (magnetic), every time. Thermal overload never operates. After reset the same sequence repeats. The motor had been reliable for eight years until a panel overhaul last week, when the star-delta timer was replaced.
Plant & Installation Context
Star-delta starter in a Form 4 Type 2 MCC: KM1 line contactor, KM2 star, KM3 delta, mechanical interlock between KM2 and KM3, electrical NC interlocking, electronic on-delay timer (set 8 s). Motor: 18.5 kW, 400 V Δ / 690 V Y, 32.0 A, IE3. Incoming 40 A MCCB (Ir = 36 A, Ii = 10 Ir). Panel overhaul replaced the pneumatic star-delta timer with a DIN-rail electronic timer; auxiliary wiring was disturbed. No VFD, no soft-starter.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 4: Type AC RCD Blinded by PV DC Leakage
Reported Symptom
Six-monthly RCD test of a 30 mA device protecting a kitchen ring fails the 1 × I_Δn test at both 0° and 180° (no trip within 300 ms). The 5 × I_Δn test is delayed (>40 ms). The test button still trips. Occupants report the RCD has never tripped in service. A 4 kW transformerless string inverter was added on the same TT consumer unit two years ago. The ring itself has no history of faults.
Plant & Installation Context
TT domestic installation, Ra = 48 Ω, 100 mA S-type time-delayed RCD at origin and 30 mA Type AC RCCB (BS EN 61008) as the main 30 mA device for sockets (Reg 411.3.3). 4 kW G98 transformerless PV inverter on a dedicated Type B 16 A MCB, sharing the same Type AC 30 mA RCCB as the socket circuits (installer used the existing split-load board). Inverter running at 3.1 kW, clear midday. Kitchen ring: 2.5 mm², IR healthy.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 5: Third-Harmonic Neutral Overload on Balanced LED Lighting
Reported Symptom
A three-phase lighting board serving a retail floor smells of hot PVC after six hours of trading. Phase MCBs (100 A) are cool and have never tripped. The incoming 4-core 35 mm² SWA is hot on the neutral core only. Clamp measurements show ~100 A per phase but 180 A in the neutral. The DNO has not reported a supply fault. All three phases of LED luminaires are evenly loaded.
Plant & Installation Context
400 V TN-S commercial distribution. Sub-main: 35 mm² 4-core SWA (Cu), 100 A TP MCCB, 42 m to an 8-way TP lighting board. Load: approximately 90 kW of LED panel luminaires with cheap switch-mode drivers, balanced across L1/L2/L3 by circuit count. Neutral of the SWA is 35 mm² (same as phase). No harmonic filter, no k-rated transformer. Board installed 2016 for fluorescent; luminaires swapped to LED in 2024 without redesign.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 6: PME Broken Supply PEN with Diverted Return Currents
Reported Symptom
Touch voltage of approximately 58 V felt on boiler casing and wet tap in a 3-phase TN-C-S (PME) workshop. Clamp meter on 22 mm copper water main shows 19 A flowing on pipework. Apprentice suspects a live pipe or a leaking immersion heater element energising the water system. All RCCBs hold in and do not trip. Insulation resistance tests read greater than 200 Mohm, ruling out a local insulation breakdown. Shock risk is worse at wet locations.
Plant & Installation Context
3-phase TN-C-S (PME) workshop supplied by 100 A DNO service. Copper water and gas services bonded at the main earthing terminal (MET). Load includes an 18 kW single-phase welder connected on L1, causing significant neutral current and phase imbalance.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 7: High-Resistance Neutral-Earth Fault on Idle Circuit Tripping RCD
Reported Symptom
30 mA Type A RCCB trips only when the 9.5 kW shower or the 32 A oven is switched on; it holds with light loads. The shower tests healthy with insulation resistance above 299 Mohm. Apprentice blames a faulty RCD or a breaking-down shower element. An idle 20 A garage radial with its single-pole MCB switched off is assumed dead and overlooked.
Plant & Installation Context
TN-S commercial distribution board with a 30 mA Type A RCCB feeding a 9.5 kW shower, a 32 A oven circuit, and a 20 A garage radial. The garage radial is switched off at a single-pole MCB, which breaks the line only and leaves its neutral connected to the neutral bar.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 8: VFD Inverter High dv/dt Induced Shaft Bearing EDM Fluting
Reported Symptom
22 kW motor bearings fail every 5 to 8 months with blackened grease and washboard (fluting) raceway marks. Motor windings pass a 500 V insulation test at greater than 200 Mohm. Maintenance crew keeps fitting standard bearings and blames mechanical misalignment, but alignment checks and replacement bearings do not extend life.
Plant & Installation Context
22 kW IE3 400 V induction motor on continuous-duty centrifugal pump, fed from a 15 kHz PWM variable-frequency drive via 38 m of unscreened or poorly terminated cable with pigtail EMC gland connections.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 9: Soft Starter Shorted SCR Causing DC Injection and Inrush Trip
Reported Symptom
On start, the 75 kW stone crusher motor emits a violent growl with severe vibration followed by immediate tripping of the Type C MCCB. Maintenance suspects a jammed crusher jaw or a phase-to-phase stator winding fault (red herring). However, cold winding resistance is balanced across all three phases with no evidence of a winding short, and the crusher jaw turns freely by hand when isolated.
Plant & Installation Context
75 kW 400 V 3-phase stone crusher motor fed via a 6-SCR anti-parallel soft starter with internal bypass contactor, protected by a Type C MCCB. TN-S supply arrangement. Soft starter controls voltage ramp at start; bypass contactor is confirmed open during starting. Load is a high-inertia crusher.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 10: Distinguishing Real Series Arc from Inverter / Commutator Noise
Reported Symptom
The AFDD-RCBO protecting the first-floor ring final circuit trips intermittently whenever a vacuum cleaner is operated, also affecting LED luminaires on the same circuit. The apprentice assumes nuisance tripping from vacuum motor brush hash (red herring) and replaces the AFDD with a standard MCB, but the underlying overheating joint remains and the replacement removes arc protection.
Plant & Installation Context
TN-C-S dwelling. First-floor ring final circuit to BS 7671:2018+A2:2022, protected by a BS EN 62606 AFDD-RCBO installed per Regulation 421.1.7. Circuit feeds general socket-outlets (used by vacuum cleaner) and ceiling rose lighting points including LED luminaires.
Select Your Diagnostic Hypothesis:
Statutory & Engineering Rationale:
Practical Rectification Procedure:
Case 11: Solar PV Array Morning DC Isolation Fault (Riso) Localization
Reported Symptom
The transformerless string inverter flags 'Isolation Fault / Low Riso' (error E018) every morning at dawn but clears and generates normally by midday. The apprentice tests only the AC side and replaces the Type B RCD (red herring), but the fault recurs the next damp morning because the defect is on the DC array side and tracks through morning dew.
Plant & Installation Context
6.6 kW rooftop solar array, 2 strings of 8 modules each, feeding a transformerless string inverter with TN-C-S AC connection. DC side operates around 328 V string Voc. Inverter monitors DC insulation resistance (Riso) to earth per IEC 62109-2 with a 500 kohm trip threshold.